Sell Us Your Cards - Terms


-I Read The Rules and Process, Click Here to Continue-

Alternative Method For MTG


Selling Singles: Read All The Rules

Step 1- To begin selling singles you must be Logged In to your Games A Plunder account.

Step 2 - SORT YOUR CARDS, And keep them in the order you list them

Step 3 Use the search bar to find the cards you wish to sell and add quantities to your cart using the “SELL” tab. Making sure to match the correct set release and condition of each card.

Step 4 -  Please keep the cards in the EXACT ORDER shown in your cart. Please note that there will be a delay in processing your order if it arrives out of order and a fee of up to 15% of your total may be applied. We may also choose to reject your order completely.

Step 5 -  Double check if you selected Cash or Store Credit, then you can click “Submit List”

NOTE - All buylists are to brought to the store within 7 business days. After that time, we may cancel and delete your buylist. 

Step 6 - Please carefully package and ship or drop off the cards to our store address. If you would like to be notified before your payment is sent or credit applied you must let us know at this point.

Games A Plunder

107 Union Street

Cobleskill, NY 12043

BUY ORDER # ________

Buylists MUST be delivered to our store location, by mail or in person.
You are responsible for the cost of shipping on returned cards.

NOTE: Please write your buy order number on the outside of the package as indicated below. Do not put cards in plastic zip lock bags or wrap them with rubber bands. We highly recommend packaging your cards in boxes designed to hold trading cards with padding, to prevent them from movement or damage during shipping/transit.

We strongly recommend that you purchase tracking and insurance for your package. Occasionally packages are lost or damaged in transit and we are not responsible for mistakes made by mail carriers.

*CARD CONDITIONS*: Cards will be checked by staff when received to determine actual condition. See: TCG Player Card Condition Guide


Fake/Proxy/Counterfeit/etc. will NOT be returned.

You will NOT receive any Cash or Credit or Reimbursement for the counterfeit cards.

In the event you have accidentally/unknowingly sent us a counterfeit card(s), we will notify you and dispose of the card(s).

New Release Cards

  • We will not buy card singles until 7 days after the release date.


  • Payouts will be issued once buylist has been received and checked. Cash will be held at the store or paid via PayPal, and store credit will be deposited to your account.
  • Any PayPal fees will be deducted from your total payment.
  • We are not responsible to pay any shipping costs for any cards sent to us. We are not responsible to pay any shipping costs to return cards.


  • We ask that all buylists sent to us are received at our store within 7 business days. After that time, we may cancel and delete your buylist. 

-All prices are subject to change based on market value and current card stock. 

-Our buylists are provided for your information only and should not be considered as a guaranteed offer to buy.

-Buy list prices and quantities in demand are subject to change at any time, and we reserve the right to refuse any cards for any reason.



-We do not purchase Oversized Cards or Art Cards


F.A.Q - Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How long does the grading process take?

    Time can fluctuate depending on how many cards you have in your buylist, and how many other customers have also submitted buylists ahead of yours. Generally it will take about a week or less, but this is not a guarantee.

  2. Do you contact me with the results before finalizing my order?

    In order to keep the process as fast as possible, we will only contact you with the results if you contact us in advance in regards to the buylist, or tell us when you drop off the cards. Otherwise, your order will be reviewed and finalized as quickly as possible.

  3. Can I change my mind and get my cards back after my order is finalized?

    The only way we can provide you a return of your cards, if you change your mind regarding the offered price, is if you have emailed us in advance of the buylist order requesting that you be contacted with the results before finalization or have told us when you dropped off the cards. Once we’ve finalized an order, the order is committed to our live inventory. There will be no way to tell which cards are yours at that point, so we will not be able to return the cards to you if you change your mind.